Home   Author   Articles   Archives   Links  
Striper
Wars
   
Eye of
the Whale
   
Black
Genius
   
The Man Who
Knew Too Much
   
Jesse
Ventura


   Index

5/8/2014

New Chinese Mega-Resort Plan
Threatens Baja Coral Reef

By Dick Russell

In mid-June of 2012, following months of protests by environmentalists, the Mexican government announced the cancellation of permits to build a massive resort complex along the shoreline of the only productive coral reef in Baja’s Gulf of California. At the time, a Spanish developer had plans for some 30,000 hotel rooms, golf courses and a marina beside the Cabo Pulmo National Marine Park. But scientific studies showed that marine life had exploded since the reef received protection from overfishing in 1995. This, coupled with Madrid builder Hansa Urbana’s financial instability, resulted in the project’s being abandoned.

But not for long, it turns out. Cabo Cortés has now reared its ugly head as Cabo Dorado. In mid-March, a Chinese consortium submitted an environmental impact statement to Mexican authorities, seeking to construct an “integrally planned development….of 9 hotels totaling 4,080 rooms and 6,141 residences” over a ten-year period. Not to mention 4,380 commercial spaces, restaurants and condos; an improved airfield, a shopping center, several beach clubs, two golf courses, a shooting range and a wellness center. An investment that the developers say will reach $3.6 billion will be scattered across some 9,316 acres. The builders’ press release claims they “will employ directly and indirectly around 18,000 people” and “will have an economic spillover of around $900 million dollars per annum.”

On the “plus side,” the Cabo Dorado plan doesn’t include a marina or a desalination plant – both on the drawing board for the earlier Cabo Cortés project, and both considered to pose huge risks to the marine reserve. The latest developer alleges that the Cabo Dorado Project will maintain “around 67% of the land….as a natural reserve dedicated to the conservation of the environment.” But it’s all to be erected adjacent to what National Geographic has called the most robust coral reserve in the world – home to more than 260 marine species including manta rays, sharks and sea turtles, and a critical stopover for migrating humpback whales. About half a million tons of food (marine nutrients and fish) are exported annually from the park’s environs. It’s a UNESCO World Heritage Site (as of 2005), and a RAMSAR global wetland of international importance (2008).

The Chinese apparently bought the water rights that its Spanish predecessor had put in place, which allow the pumping of more than four million cubic meters annually from the Santiago and Cabo Pulmo aquifers. This is a desert region where rainfall is already down dramatically. (Over the past decade, the supply of water per resident in the nearby Los Cabos municipality has dropped by half.) And the Santiago aquifer is the last remaining water reserve of consequence in all of Baja California Sur. It’s been estimated that the amount of water consumed only by Cabo Dorado’s proposed hotels – without considering water demands from any other infrastructure – would be more than 11 million cubic meters of water per year. That’s almost three times the allotted water rights.

So it makes you wonder where the rest is going to come from. Of course, even if the land deal again goes bust, the developer’s water concession would put them in a position to sell the water back to the people of the area (as the Nestle corporation did in Bolivia). If you find the notion of draining the pesos from the locals a bit diabolical, consider that the newly-elected PRI government just forced through legislation to denationalize and sell off the Mexican oil fields to the highest bidders. Consider, too, that the environmental impact statement for Cabo Dorado was prepared by the same people who did one for the previous Cabo Cortés project. And consider that the Mexican promoter is, yet again, a shadowy fellow in Mexico City named John McCarthy, who used to head up the country’s tourism development agency, Fonatur.

In this case, Mexico’s deal is with La Rivera Desarrollos BCS, holding company of Cabo Dorado properties, with the majority owner being two companies: Beijing Sansong International Trade Group and Glorious Earth Holdings. The latter is based in Irvine, California, founded as Glorious Earth Group in 2013 and privately held. An Internet search doesn’t reveal much that’s glorious. In fact, the company’s website sounds like it was put together by someone just starting to master the English language. It’s allegedly “a construction company with worldwide projection….a solid company with extensive experience in the design and implementation of infrastructure for ground transportation.” Under the heading of “Hydroelectric Plants,” we are informed that “Glorious Earth Group is known for offering our best effort in every work.” Supposedly the company “has huge experience in Renewable Energy,” although nothing is specified. The registered agent for the (not-so) Glorious Earth Group is Yurong Zhang.

As for Beijing Sansong, it’s a multimillion-dollar company whose partners include the top three international contractors by total revenue in the world. The China State Construction and Engineering Corporation, slated to build Cabo Dorado, has completed over 5,000 projects in 116 countries over the past three decades. It reported $57 billion in international revenues in 2011. Two years before that, it was one of seven companies debarred by the World Bank for attempted bid-rigging in a major bank-financed project in the Philippines.

Octavio Aburto-Oporeza is a marine biologist and Assistant Professor at Scripps Institution of Oceanography, whose studies revealed that Cabo Pulmo’s biomass of marine life more than quadrupled in the decade after the reef received protection. As he describes the Cabo Dorado project: “It’s not like asking to build a bathroom in your backyard. If you look at the scale of the project in the long-term, it is building a city of 250,000 people.” Agustín Bravo, Northwest Coordinator of the Mexican Center for Environmental Law, see many factors that could affect the marine reserve, including the large increase in visitors, polluted runoff from golf courses irrigated by treated water, and changes in the sediments that flow into the Sea of Cortés. Bravo has called this “a privatization of environmental services and socialization of environmental liabilities. It’s crony capitalism.”

Clearly, the latest fight to protect the reef and its surrounding environment has only begun. To keep regularly abreast of what’s going on, visit the websites of two grassroots organizations involved in the effort: www.wildcoast.net and www.cabopulmovivo.org.

6/10/2014

Victory for Baja's Sea of Cortez

Following an amazing public outcry (millions of web hits and hundreds of thousands of tweets and emails over the past several weeks), Mexico's SEMARNAT environmental agency has rejected the current Cabo Dorado development plan and environmental impact statement from the Chinese developers.

The Chinese must now return to square one, completely redesign their proposal and development and draft a completely new environmental impact statement. This is a huge setback for them and a clear message that the tide is turning against irresponsible mega-developments in the Baja.

Here's a link to the announcement (in Spanish): Inversionistas retiran Proyecto Cabo Dorado en BCS

Here's a slightly jumbled machine translation of the story into English including quotes from a former minister of the environment:

MEXICO CITY, May 30 - Investors in Cabo Dorado Friday announced publicly that they were removing their application to the Mexican Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources (SEMARNAT) for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) of the controversial tourism development intended to be built near the Cabo Pulmo National Marine Park in Baja California Sur.

In a letter sent to scientists and civil society to Excelsior, Victor Lichtinger Waisman, in charge of Semarnat during the administration of Vicente Fox Quesada, revealed that the American-Chinese consortium behind the project took this decision after considering as "devastating" the arguments in recent months against Cabo Dorado.

"And it has been thought that as the situation is not worth continuing in this environmental assessment process," he said.

Lichtinger, who led the country's environmental policy from 2000 to 2003, said the idea is to redefine the proposal and resubmit an EIA "totally new for approval of SEMARNAT."

The Ph.D. in Agricultural and Natural Resources stressed that his conviction that "any new proposals should be worked on completely different to what the promoters of this project have done so far, and the project should be radically different and of considerably less magnitude".

Victor Lichtinger added that he recommended investors to withdraw all legal procedures and remedies of the previous project known as Cabo Cortés, as this only creates distrust and decreases the chances of having a proposal that "have a clear social license."


Home   Author   Articles   Archives   Links  

 
click on the whale to send email